Sam is not Wooly

^^ agreed, but other than that I think everything checks out

My theory is that Sam is the barn house

There's that too, but I believe he was most likely either dead or the person who broke into the attic

@BunnyCake52 @Squishy-Marshmallow I don't quite understand why everyone thinks sam is the barn house..? The barn house still has bloodshot eyes and breathes heavily even if you type in the correct answer.