I've actually seen a theory that Wooly might actually be Balam (one of the demons in the ars Goetia) which would explain why in that special tape in the first game where Rebecca was saying demon names she said Balam as "Baa Lamb"

It would also explain why Amanda hates him so much and why he was constantly seen kind of scaring/tormenting Amanda in clips during the glitching tape in the second game

Wow, i like this theory

This is a theory i agree with!!! It makes sense but in my opinion we would also have to know how rebecca feels about hameln to like see if the feeling matches with wooly

K this is random lmao

But many people say that wooly is the innocent guy but when i started watching i felt like something was off with wooly so i think wooly is the bad guy and maybe Amanda tryna protect us or something? idk tbh I'm still new to this lol

But back to topic i agree with half of what you said

And i know which Hameln worker it is, watch credits 'In your neighborhood', Danny McQuiggin. CONTAINMENT specialist, what is he countaining? Why is he mentioned? What even is a Containment Specialist? Theres a pretty convincing theory about that this guy is Wooly so im stating my point to spread the word about it and see if anyone can find evidence, also we dont even know if Sam's dead, also why would Wooly act like a scared and confused child in the kitchen? plus he seems to not question being in the game, its as if he knows what he's for and what he's there to do, he seems to keep Amanda from getting mad and finding out who she actually is

I've seen a lot of wooly theories, like he is Sam colton and since he has a connection to kids, they use him to lead kids into the Tapes, and I've also seen these types of theories that wooly is evil, like the we can fix it tape, he looms over Amanda, also he might have not known the entity could attack her (Probably) And other theory, that the real wooly died in the first game and this is a different wooly, but it would make sense he was a hamelin employee.

It's unlikely that it was Sam, Sam was completely against Hameln's intentions, and Amanda would have treated Wooly more positively then